Climbing Shoe Comparison: Scarpa Instinct vs So Ill Street
Climbing shoes are an essential item for any climber, both indoors and outdoors. They provide support, grip, and comfort to ensure that climbers can perform their best. But with so many different models on the market, it can be overwhelming to find the right shoe for your climbing needs. This article will compare the Scarpa Instinct and the So Ill Street to help make the decision easier.
Comparison Table
| Feature | Scarpa Instinct | So Ill Street |
|---|---|---|
| Fit | Aggressive | Slightly Aggressive |
| Type of Climbing | Bouldering, Sport, Trad | Bouldering |
| Sole Stiffness | Medium | Medium |
| Shape | Hook-and-Loop | Slipper |
| Closure System | Hook-and-Loop | Elastic |
| Materials | Synthetic | Synthetic |
| Toe Box Shape | Pointed | Round |
| Heel Cup | High | Low |
| Weight | 8.4 oz. | 8.4 oz. |
| Level of Ventilation | Low | Low |
Fit
The Scarpa Instinct offers a more aggressive fit compared to the So Ill Street. This means that it wraps tightly around the foot and provides more support. It also offers a more precise fit, which is good for climbers who are looking for a sock-like feel while they climb. The So Ill Street has a slightly more aggressive fit, but it’s still a bit more forgiving than the Instinct. This makes it a great choice for climbers who want to stay comfortable while still having a secure fit.
The Instinct also has an asymmetric shape, which helps with edging and heel hooking. This can be beneficial for climbers who are looking to advance their skills. The Street, on the other hand, has a symmetrical shape, which is better for smearing and heel hooking.
Type of Climbing
The Scarpa Instinct is designed for all types of climbing, including bouldering, sport, and trad. It provides the support and grip needed for all types of climbing. The So Ill Street, however, is designed for bouldering specifically. It’s a great choice for climbers who are mostly bouldering, but it doesn’t offer the same support and grip as the Instinct for other types of climbing.
Sole Stiffness
Both the Scarpa Instinct and the So Ill Street have medium sole stiffness. This means that they offer enough support for climbing without making the foot feel too restricted. The Instinct is a bit stiffer than the Street, which can help with edging and heel hooking. The Street is a bit more flexible, which can be beneficial for smearing and heel hooking.
Shape
The Scarpa Instinct has a hook-and-loop shape, which provides a secure and comfortable fit. The Velcro straps are adjustable and can be tightened or loosened depending on the fit needed. The So Ill Street has a slipper shape, which is more comfortable and forgiving than the Instinct. The elastic closure system offers a snug fit, but it doesn’t offer the same support as the Instinct.
Closure System
The Scarpa Instinct has a hook-and-loop closure system, which provides a secure and adjustable fit. The So Ill Street has an elastic closure system, which is comfortable but doesn’t offer the same level of support as the Instinct.
Materials
Both the Scarpa Instinct and the So Ill Street are made of synthetic materials. The Instinct has a synthetic upper and a rubber sole, while the Street has a synthetic upper and a rubber sole. The Instinct also has an additional layer of rubber on the toe and heel for extra protection and durability.
Price
The Scarpa Instinct and the So Ill Street are both priced around the same range. The Instinct is slightly more expensive, but it’s a high-quality shoe that will last a long time. The Street is slightly less expensive, but it doesn’t offer the same level of support and protection as the Instinct.Personal Preference
When it comes to choosing the right climbing shoe, it ultimately comes down to personal preference. The Scarpa Instinct offers a more aggressive fit, which is great for climbers who are looking for a secure and precise fit. The So Ill Street has a more forgiving fit, which is better for climbers who want to stay comfortable while still having a secure fit. Both shoes offer medium sole stiffness and are made of high-quality materials, so it really comes down to personal preference.
Toe Box Shape
The Scarpa Instinct has a pointed toe box, which is great for edging and toe hooks. The So Ill Street has a round toe box, which is better for smearing and heel hooks. Both shoes offer enough room for the toes to move comfortably, so climbers should choose the one that best fits their climbing style.
Heel Cup
The Scarpa Instinct has a high heel cup, which provides more support and protection for the feet. The So Ill Street has a low heel cup, which is more comfortable but doesn’t offer the same level of support as the Instinct.
Weight
Both the Scarpa Instinct and the So Ill Street are lightweight shoes. The Instinct weighs 8.4 oz., while the Street weighs 8.4 oz. The Instinct is slightly heavier due to the additional layer of rubber on the toe and heel, but both shoes are still lightweight enough to move quickly and easily on the wall.
Level of Ventilation
The Scarpa Instinct and the So Ill Street both have a low level of ventilation. This means they will keep the feet warm on cold days, but they won’t provide the same level of breathability as some other climbing shoes.
Conclusion
The Scarpa Instinct and the So Ill Street are both great options for climbers who are looking for a secure and comfortable fit. The Instinct offers a more aggressive fit and more support, while the Street has a more forgiving fit and is better for smearing and heel hooks. Both shoes are lightweight and made of high-quality materials, so it ultimately comes down to personal preference.